Cooperstown
106 Chestnut St
Cooperstown, NY 13326

888-258-4209
Fax: 607-547-9193

Our Companies

Claim Phone:

800-333-7642

Claim URL:

claims@preferredmutual.com

Website URL:

https://www.preferredmutual.com/

Policy Questions:

(803) 255-8891

Website URL:

http://www.dovetailinsurance.com/

Foremost Insurance
Foremost Insurance
Claim Phone:

800-527-3907

Claim URL:

http://www.foremost.com/claims

Policy Questions:

800-527-3905

Billing Phone:

800-532-4221

Billing URL:

http://www.foremost.com/payonline/agent.asp

Website URL:

http://www.foremost.com/

Claim Phone:

866-424-8508

Claim URL:

http://www.hiscox.com/small-business-insurance/business-insurance-claims/

Policy Questions:

866-283-7545

Policy Questions URL:

http://www.hiscox.com/contact-us/

Website URL:

http://www.hiscox.com/

K&K Insurance Group Logo
K&K Insurance Group Logo
Claim Phone:

1-800-237-2917

Claim URL:

http://www.kandkinsurance.com/Pages/Claims.aspx

Policy Questions:

1-800-637-4757

Policy Questions URL:

http://www.kandkinsurance.com/Pages/ContactUs.aspx

Website URL:

http://www.kandkinsurance.com/

Claim Phone:

877-425-2467

Claim URL:

http://www.msagroup.com/policyholder/reportingClaims.cfm

Policy Questions:

800-207-0446

Policy Questions URL:

http://www.msagroup.com/aboutmsa/contact.cfm

Billing Phone:

888-333-4014

Billing URL:

http://www.msagroup.com/policyholder/paymentoptions.cfm

Website URL:

http://www.msagroup.com/

Safeco
Safeco
Claim Phone:

800-332-3226

Claim URL:

http://www.safeco.com/claims-center

Policy Questions:

800-332-3226

Print proof of insurance:

https://customer.safeco.com/accountservices/login.aspx

Billing Phone:

1-888-723-3260

Billing URL:

https://www.safeco.com/customer-resources/customer-support/billing-and-payment

Website URL:

http://www.safeco.com/

Travelers Insurance
Travelers Insurance
Claim Phone:

800-252-4633

Claim URL:

https://www.travelers.com/claims/report-claim/index.aspx

Policy Questions:

800-842-5075

Print proof of insurance:

http://mytravelers.com/ESERV/MyTravSplash.aspx

Billing Phone:

800-842-5075

Billing URL:

https://www.travelers.com/online-service

Website URL:

http://www.travelers.com/

Claim URL:

https://www.uticafirst.com/claimsProcess.html

Policy Questions:

1-800-456-4556

Policy Questions URL:

https://www.uticafirst.com/contact.html

Website URL:

https://www.uticafirst.com/

Allstate
Allstate
Claim Phone:

1-800-255-7828

Claim URL:

http://www.allstate.com/claims/report-claim.aspx

Policy Questions:

1-800-255-7828

Billing Phone:

800-901-1732

Billing URL:

https://www.allstate.com/support/payment-and-billing.aspx

Website URL:

http://www.allstate.com/

Claim Phone:

800-375-2075

Claim URL:

http://www.amig.com/customer/file-a-claim/

Policy Questions:

800-543-2644

Policy Questions URL:

http://www.amig.com/customer/

Billing Phone:

800-543-2644

Billing URL:

http://www.amig.com/customer/make-a-payment/

Website URL:

http://www.amig.com

Hagerty Insurance
Hagerty Insurance
Claim Phone:

800-922-4050 (Cars) or 800-762-2628 (Boats)

Claim URL:

https://login.hagerty.com/

Billing Phone:

800-922-4050 (Cars) or 800-762-2628 (Boats)

Billing URL:

https://www.hagerty.com/authenticate/minimal/?purpose=payroll

Website URL:

http://www.hagerty.com/

Policy Questions:

800-766-6642

Policy Questions URL:

http://madisonmutual.com/homepage/contact/

Website URL:

http://madisonmutual.com/

Mid-State Mutual Insurance Logo
Mid-State Mutual Insurance Logo
Policy Questions:

507-835-3570

Policy Questions URL:

http://www.midstatewaseca.com/contact_us.php

Website URL:

http://www.midstatewaseca.com/

GMAC Insurance
GMAC Insurance
Claim Phone:

1-800-325-1088

Claim URL:

http://www.nationalgeneral.com/claims-center/default.asp

Policy Questions:

1-800-847-2886

Policy Questions URL:

http://www.nationalgeneral.com/Contact/CustomerService.asp

Billing Phone:

1-800-847-2886

Website URL:

http://www.nationalgeneral.com/

Met Life
Met Life
Claim Phone:

800-MET-LIFE (800-638-5433)

Claim URL:

https://www.metlife.com/about/corporate-profile/pay-a-bill/claims/index.html

Policy Questions:

800-MET-LIFE (800-638-5433)

Print proof of insurance:

https://online.metlife.com/edge/web/public/login

Billing Phone:

800-680-3354

Billing URL:

https://www.metlife.com/about/corporate-profile/pay-a-bill/index.html

Website URL:

https://www.metlife.com/